What do EU rules say about amalgam, and do they require fillings to be removed?
European Union rules prohibit placing new amalgam fillings but do not require removal of those already in your teeth. Article 10 of Regulation (EU) 2017/852 on mercury, amended by Regulation (EU) 2024/1849, states that from 1 January 2025 dental amalgam must not be used for treatment unless the dentist considers it strictly necessary because of the patient’s specific medical needs.
The regulation governs amalgam use, trade, manufacture and waste, but does not require existing fillings to be replaced. The table summarises the key dates (as of November 2026).
| Date | What EU rules changed |
|---|---|
| 1 July 2018 | No amalgam in primary teeth, children under 15, or pregnant and breastfeeding women, except where strictly medically necessary |
| 1 January 2019 | Amalgam only in capsules; practices removing amalgam fillings must have amalgam separators |
| 1 January 2025 | Ban on using amalgam for treatment throughout the EU, except for specific medical needs; export ban |
| 30 June 2026 | End of the transitional period for countries where amalgam was the only material reimbursed at a rate of at least 90% |
| 1 July 2026 | Ban on amalgam import and manufacture, with the same medical exception |
Do amalgam fillings have to be replaced?
No, if the filling is intact, has not cracked and has no decay beneath it. In its 2020 recommendations, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) does not recommend removing such fillings in anyone, including pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers and children, unless a clinician considers it medically necessary.
In its 2015 opinion, the EU Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks (SCENIHR) found no general justification for removing clinically satisfactory amalgam fillings, except in people with a diagnosed allergy to their components. According to SCENIHR, the available evidence does not preclude the use of either amalgam or alternative materials.
Amalgam is approximately half mercury by weight, and a filling releases small amounts of mercury vapour (FDA). Removing a sound filling, however, means unnecessary loss of tooth tissue and a temporary increase in mercury vapour exposure. SCENIHR estimates that removal of fillings from 16 tooth surfaces involves about 40 µg of mercury in a single episode, equivalent to the total released by amalgam fillings over 2.3 to 10 days.
When does replacing an amalgam filling make sense?
Replacing an amalgam filling makes sense for the same reasons as replacing any other filling: it has cracked or chipped, its margin is leaking, or secondary decay has developed beneath or beside it. The dentist assesses this during an examination, sometimes with an X-ray.
Local reactions are a less common reason. SCENIHR describes lichenoid mucosal lesions where tissue touches an amalgam filling. These usually improved substantially after replacement, especially with a positive patch test to mercury or amalgam; one study found improvement within 3 months in 28 of 30 people. However, evidence is lacking that routinely replacing all fillings helps every patient with such lesions.
| Situation | Replace? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Intact filling, no decay or symptoms | No | The procedure removes healthy tissue and temporarily increases mercury exposure |
| Cracked, chipped or loosening filling | Yes | The tooth is no longer sealed and is exposed to decay and fracture |
| Secondary decay beneath the filling or at its margin | Yes | Decay needs removal and the cavity needs a new filling |
| Lichenoid lesion touching the filling, positive patch test | Usually yes, after investigation | Such lesions usually improved after replacement |
| Intact filling during pregnancy or breastfeeding | No, postpone | The FDA advises against removing intact fillings in these groups |
| Dark filling in a visible area, purely cosmetic reasons | Possible as an informed choice | The cost includes some tooth tissue and temporary mercury vapour exposure |
| Unexplained systemic symptoms attributed to mercury | Not as a treatment | Symptoms also improved without removing fillings |
How is amalgam removed with precautions?
Removing an amalgam filling releases mercury vapour, and the amount depends on technique. SCENIHR lists the number of fillings removed at once, water cooling, suction efficiency and use of a rubber dam, a sheet that isolates the tooth from the rest of the mouth, among the relevant factors. Since 1 January 2019, practices removing amalgam fillings must have amalgam separators, since 1 January 2021 every separator in use must retain at least 95% of amalgam particles, and a specialist company collects amalgam waste (Article 10 of Regulation 2017/852).
- Before the procedure, the dentist assesses which fillings actually need replacement and plans the order.
- If several fillings are involved, you can ask about staged treatment, because the number removed at once affects mercury release.
- Ask how the tooth will be isolated and how water containing material fragments will be suctioned away.
- According to the FDA, swallowing a small amalgam fragment has no known health risk; inhaling mercury vapour is the greater concern.
Amalgam fillings during pregnancy and breastfeeding: replace or wait?
During pregnancy and breastfeeding, elective replacement of intact amalgam fillings is best postponed. The FDA includes women who are pregnant, planning pregnancy or breastfeeding among groups potentially more sensitive to mercury. For that very reason it advises against removing intact fillings in these groups, because removal temporarily increases mercury vapour exposure.
SCENIHR recommends limiting restorative treatment during pregnancy, like any other therapy, to what is necessary. However, a cracked filling or decay beneath one is a reason for treatment during pregnancy too, using a mercury-free material for the new filling: in the EU, amalgam has not been used for pregnant or breastfeeding women since 2018 except where strictly medically necessary.
The FDA states that mercury levels in breast milk are usually very low. Tell the dentist at every appointment if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, as this affects treatment planning.
Does detox or chelation after amalgam removal make sense?
There is no evidence that ‘mercury detox’ or chelating medicines help people with amalgam fillings or after their removal. In a randomised, double-blind trial, 50 patients who attributed their symptoms to fillings received a chelating medicine (succimer) or placebo for 5 days. The medicine increased mercury excretion in urine, but wellbeing improved equally in both groups (Grandjean et al., 1997).
SCENIHR notes that tests using chelating medicines have no additional diagnostic value and the medicines themselves can have significant adverse effects. In a study cited by the committee, symptoms attributed to amalgam improved after filling removal, but also after a health-promotion programme without removal. Start with your family doctor for unexplained symptoms such as tiredness or headaches, and do not take chelating medicines without their prescription.
What can replace an amalgam filling?
An amalgam filling is replaced with a mercury-free material: SCENIHR lists composites, glass ionomer cements, ceramics and gold alloys. Most often this is a tooth-coloured composite filling. For a large cavity with weakened cusps, the dentist may suggest an inlay or onlay made outside the mouth, or a crown.
According to the FDA, resin materials require less removal of healthy tissue than amalgam, are tooth-coloured and contain no heavy metals, but can cause allergies, and may not match amalgam’s longevity in back teeth exposed to heavy chewing forces. SCENIHR adds that large composite fillings failed more often than amalgam in people at high risk of decay. For a large molar filling, it is therefore worth discussing a laboratory-made restoration with the dentist too.
Amalgam replacement under the NFZ and privately: how much does it cost?
Under Poland’s National Health Fund (NFZ), amalgam filling removal is a separate guaranteed service performed as part of tooth treatment at a workstation with an amalgam separator; it was added to the list on 10 October 2022 (Annex 10c). For adults, the new filling is made of glass ionomer cement, or also chemically cured composite in front teeth from canine to canine.
Light-cured composite is available under the NFZ for children and young people under 18 in incisors and canines, and, where medically indicated, for people with disabilities: under 16 regardless of the degree of disability, and from 16 with a moderate or severe degree. Amalgam is not on the materials list (consolidated text Dz.U. 2025 poz. 615, Annex 11, as of November 2026). Find contracted practices in the NFZ ‘Gdzie się leczyć’ (Where to get treatment) search tool.
Privately, the replacement price depends mainly on how many tooth surfaces the new filling covers. DentalBlue’s published price list gives ‘Single-surface filling’ at 300 zł and ‘Composite inlay/onlay’ at 1 200 zł; the table lists the other items. The dentist agrees the final scope and cost at consultation, and prices may change.
| Clinic price-list item | Price |
|---|---|
| Single-surface filling | 300 zł |
| Two-surface filling | 350 zł |
| Three-surface filling | 400 zł |
| Filling of more than three surfaces | 500 zł |
| Composite inlay/onlay | 1 200 zł |
| Local anaesthetic | 60 zł |
| Intraoral radiograph | 60 zł |
Amalgam filling replacement at DentalBlue in Białystok
At DentalBlue in Białystok, assessment and replacement of old fillings form part of restorative dentistry, and intraoral and panoramic X-rays are taken in the clinic’s own radiology unit. At a ‘First visit without pain’ (300 zł), the dentist takes a panoramic X-ray, examines the teeth and prepares a written treatment plan that can identify which fillings need replacement and which do not. For pain or a cracked filling, you can attend a ‘First visit in pain’ (340 zł), which includes pain relief.
DentalBlue provides private treatment according to its published price list and NFZ-funded treatment under general anaesthesia for eligible patients. The clinic is at ul. Kazimierza Pułaskiego 35 in Białystok, at the junction with Wspólna. The ‘Pułaskiego/Wspólna’ stop, served by routes 16, 23 and 26, is 50 m from the entrance. Opening hours are Monday to Friday from 8:00 to 20:00 and Saturdays from 8:00 to 16:00.
Book by phone: 85 748 00 50 (Polish, English, Ukrainian or Russian). Say that you would like your old amalgam fillings assessed, whether anything hurts or has cracked, and whether you are pregnant or breastfeeding. Bring the following:
- previous dental images, if you have them;
- a list of medicines you take;
- your patch-test result if you have a diagnosed allergy to mercury or other metals;
- information about kidney or neurological conditions, which the FDA lists among factors associated with greater mercury sensitivity.
Frequently asked questions
Are amalgam fillings harmful to health?
An amalgam filling releases small amounts of mercury vapour, but SCENIHR concluded in 2015 that the available evidence did not preclude its use, and local reactions and allergies were rare. A sound, intact filling is therefore not removed as a precaution.
Is amalgam banned in Poland?
Yes. The EU Mercury Regulation applies directly in Poland: since 1 January 2025 amalgam has not been used in dental treatment except for specific medical needs assessed by the dentist. The ban does not apply to fillings already in teeth (as of November 2026).
How much does amalgam filling replacement cost?
DentalBlue lists a new filling from 300 zł (‘Single-surface filling’) to 500 zł (‘Filling of more than three surfaces’), and ‘Composite inlay/onlay’ at 1 200 zł. The dentist sets the final cost after examination.
Does the NFZ cover amalgam replacement?
Yes, when it forms part of tooth treatment: amalgam filling removal is a guaranteed service, and the new adult filling is made of glass ionomer cement, or also chemically cured composite in front teeth. Legal position as of November 2026.
Can all amalgam fillings be replaced at one appointment?
The number of fillings removed at once affects mercury release (SCENIHR), and every replacement costs some tooth tissue. It makes more sense to replace only those fillings that need it, in an order agreed with the dentist.
Can an amalgam filling be replaced during pregnancy?
An intact filling is not replaced during pregnancy, because the FDA advises against removal of undamaged amalgam fillings in pregnant and breastfeeding women. A cracked filling or decay is treated during pregnancy too, using mercury-free material.
Do you need a detox after amalgam removal?
No. In a placebo-controlled trial, a chelating medicine increased mercury excretion but did not improve wellbeing more than placebo (Grandjean et al., 1997), and SCENIHR warns about these medicines’ adverse effects.
Sources
- EUR-Lex: Regulation (EU) 2017/852 on mercury, Article 10, consolidated text including amendment (EU) 2024/1849 (2024)
- FDA: Information for Patients About Dental Amalgam Fillings (2020)
- SCENIHR, European Commission: The safety of dental amalgam and alternative dental restoration materials for patients and users, opinion (2015)
- Grandjean P et al., J Occup Environ Med: chelation in patients with symptoms attributed to amalgam, placebo-controlled trial (1997)
- Dz.U. 2025 poz. 615: rozporządzenie MZ w sprawie świadczeń gwarantowanych z zakresu leczenia stomatologicznego (Minister of Health regulation on guaranteed dental services), consolidated text, Annexes 10c and 11 (2025)
- DentalBlue: price list (2026)
An informational article. It does not replace a consultation, and treatment decisions are made during a visit.




